TickValue gourd markTickValue

Futures Basics · Part 7 of 7 · Back to the index

Cash Settlement vs Physical Delivery

At expiry, a futures contract must be resolved. For most financial contracts that means cash. For commodities it can mean actual goods — and knowing which is which is not academic.

The two mechanisms

Cash settledPhysically delivered
At expiryDifference paid in cashGoods change hands
Who it affectsEveryone with a positionPositions still open at first notice / last trading day
Cost to resolveNone beyond the P/LStorage, transport, insurance, inspection
Typical contractsIndices, FX, interest rates, most cash-settled commoditiesGrains, metals, energy, livestock, softs

Which is which

Cash settledPhysically delivered
ES, NQ, YM, RTY (index futures)CL, B (crude oil, Brent)
6E, 6B, 6J, 6A (currency futures)GC, SI, HG (gold, silver, copper)
ZB, ZN, ZF, ZT (treasury futures)ZC, ZS, ZW (corn, soybeans, wheat)
HE (lean hogs)LE, GF (live and feeder cattle)
Most index and rate derivativesKC, SB, CT (coffee, sugar, cotton)

Note lean hogs vs live cattle. HE is cash settled against the lean hog index — you never receive pork. LE delivers actual animals. Two contracts in the same industry, opposite resolution mechanisms. Always check the specification rather than assuming agriculture means delivery.

How the settlement price is determined

MethodUsed byHow it works
Index value at expiryES, NQSpecial opening quotation built from constituent prices
Exchange reference rate6E, 6JOfficial fixing at a specified time
Cash market indexHE, and some dairyWeighted average of reported cash trades
Delivery against warehouse receiptsGrains, metalsHolder presents a receipt; goods transfer

The settlement price can differ from the last traded price. Index futures settle on a special opening quotation computed from where the underlying stocks actually open — not from where the future last traded. That gap can be a full tick or more, which is why some traders close index futures before expiry rather than carry them through.

Why a speculator should care

If you close your position before expiry, the mechanism does not touch you. It matters in three situations:

  1. You forget. A physical contract still open at first notice day creates a real delivery obligation. Brokers handle this by raising margin sharply or force-closing, and both are unwelcome surprises.
  2. You hold through roll without rolling. Nothing rolls automatically. See rolls explained.
  3. Storage fills up. Physical delivery depends on someone being able to take the goods. When they cannot, prices distort violently.

The April 2020 case

WTI crude futures settled at negative $37.63 on 20 April 2020. The mechanism: WTI delivers at Cushing, Oklahoma, an inland tank farm. Storage was full. Anyone still long at expiry faced an obligation to accept 1,000 barrels with nowhere to put them — so holders paid others to take the obligation.

Brent, which delivers by ship, could not go negative in the same way: a cargo can always be redirected or stored at sea. Same tick value, same contract size, completely different tail risk. See Brent vs WTI.

Practical rules

Where to go next

Back to Futures Basics, or straight to the specification table to check the settlement method for any of the 135 contracts covered here.