ES vs NQ: S&P 500 or Nasdaq-100?
Both are quarterly index futures that trade almost around the clock. The difference is not which is bigger — it is that NQ moves further in percentage terms, so a point-based stop that works on ES will be hit far more often on NQ.
Side by side
| Sym | Contract | Unit | Tick size | Tick value | Point value | Months |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| ES | E-mini S&P 500 | $50 x Index Value | 0.25 | $12.5 | $50 | H,M,U,Z |
| NQ | E-mini Nasdaq-100 | $20 x Index Value | 0.25 | $5 | $20 | H,M,U,Z |
| MES | Micro E-mini S&P 500 | $5 x S&P Index | 0.25 | $1.25 | $5 | H,M,U,Z |
| MNQ | Micro E-mini Nasdaq-100 | $2 x Nasdaq-100 Index | 0.25 | $0.5 | $2 | H,M,U,Z |
The mistake sizing by tick value alone
NQ's tick value ($5) is smaller than ES's ($12.50), which leads traders to assume NQ is the safer contract. That is backwards.
| ES | NQ | |
|---|---|---|
| Index level (example) | 6,000 | 21,000 |
| Typical daily range | ~0.9% | ~1.3% |
| Daily range in points | ~54 points | ~273 points |
| Value of that range | $2,700 | $5,460 |
NQ moves roughly five times further in points and twice as far in dollars. Stop distances must be scaled to the contract's volatility, not carried over from another product.
Sizing example
$50,000 account, 1% risk = $500 per trade.
| ES stop 12 pts | NQ stop 60 pts | MES stop 12 pts | MNQ stop 60 pts | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Risk per contract | 48 ticks × $12.50 = $600 | 240 ticks × $5 = $1,200 | $60 | $120 |
| Fits $500 budget? | ❌ overshoot | ❌ overshoot | ✅ 8 contracts | ✅ 4 contracts |
Notice that neither full-size contract fits a $50,000 account at a 1% risk budget with those stops. The micros do. This is the single most common sizing error in index futures.
What each index actually is
| ES | NQ | |
|---|---|---|
| Constituents | 500 large US companies | 100 largest non-financial Nasdaq names |
| Weighting | Market-cap | Modified cap — concentration capped |
| Sector bias | Broad, with financials and industrials | Heavy technology and semiconductors |
| Rate sensitivity | Moderate | High — long-duration earnings |
| Behaviour in risk-off | Falls | Usually falls harder |
Why traders hold both
The spread between NQ and ES is itself a view: long NQ / short ES expresses "growth and tech leadership continue", the reverse expresses "rotation into value". Both legs are highly liquid, which makes the pair unusually easy to execute for a relative-value trade.
Which to start with
MES. It has the deepest book of any micro, the tightest spread relative to tick value, and the most forgiving stop distances of the four. Move to ES when one contract fits your risk budget comfortably; consider NQ only when you are actively sizing by volatility rather than by points.
See ES vs MES for the full-size versus micro comparison, and the specification table for every index contract.
Frequently asked
Is NQ more volatile than ES?
Yes — roughly 1.4× the daily percentage range on average. That is why its point-based stops must be wider.
Does one NQ contract cost less than one ES?
In margin, usually similar or slightly less. In tick value, NQ is $5 against ES's $12.50. In actual dollar risk for a comparable percentage move, NQ is usually higher.
Can I trade NQ with a $10,000 account?
Only as MNQ. One NQ contract with a sane stop risks several hundred dollars — more than most risk budgets allow on that account size.